Opinion | Staff Editorials

A hazy affair

There’s a lot we don’t know about why the fraternity Zeta Beta Tau lost its brownstone on 113th Street last month.

We don’t know anything about the initial incident that prompted the Inter-Greek Council Judicial Board to recommend revoking ZBT’s charter and taking away its house. We don’t know why former Dean of Student Affairs Kevin Shollenberger decided to overrule the Judicial Board and allow ZBT to keep its house, or what the terms of its probation plan were. And we don’t know what violation prompted the administration to evict ZBT from the brownstone and convert it into general housing.

Transparency is a buzzword that gets thrown around a lot, but there’s a reason for that. Institutions often pay lip service to this idea only to act in ways that fall far short of achieving transparency, and the Columbia administration is no exception. 

A transparent process would enable us to have a more effective understanding of a taboo topic: hazing. The administration is pushing broader education and awareness of hazing among student groups this year, and the incident that triggered ZBT’s probation involved hazing. However, the University’s definition of hazing is extremely broad. If the definition is going to be broad, specific violations must be explained. Students cannot be expected to change a culture of hazing if no one has any idea what sort of activity, in practice, constitutes a hazing violation.

Additionally, we know that many details of the ZBT saga, while not public knowledge, exist in the shadowy corners of rumor and hearsay, discussed among students in lieu of official information. Administrative transparency is necessary to prevent rumors from getting out of control and creating a damaging stigma against members of student groups. The current lack of transparency might help the University maintain a positive image, but it sacrifices student well-being, and such a sacrifice is unacceptable.

When a major decision is made that substantially affects the student body—and the determinations of which groups control the brownstones on 113th and 114th streets are major decisions—transparency from the administration toward the student body is absolutely necessary.

Transparency is also essential if the University wants to prevent allegations of preferential treatment. Contrast the handling of ZBT’s house to the email sent by Shollenberger in December condemning a flyer posted by the Columbia University Marching Band. Why was one incident dealt with in a campus-wide email, while another was hashed out behind closed doors? With a transparent process, the campus community could at least discuss the merits of the actions of these groups, rather than getting bogged down in destructive and angry finger-pointing and animosity. Every group should be treated equally and fairly, regardless of infraction—Greek life, athletic teams, and the hundreds of other student groups that make up our exciting and diverse student life.

What do we think transparency would look like? In this case, the decision of the Inter-Greek Judicial Board and its rationale, as well as Shollenberger’s reasoning, should be made public and distributed in some way: a statement to campus publications, a school-wide email, or something similar.

We understand that there are often important privacy concerns that must be balanced when the administration communicates disciplinary information. That should not be an excuse to withhold crucial decisions from the student body, which, in the end, is most affected by the administration’s actions.

We don’t know exactly why ZBT lost its house, but going forward, we hope that this mishandled process will be a catalyst for a more transparent administration.

To respond to this staff editorial, or to submit an op-ed, contact opinion@columbiaspectator.com.

Comments

Plain text

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Your username will not be displayed if checked
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Anonymous posted on

It is a private entity. It would be up to ZBT to divulge the details of the issues. Due to the sensitivity of the issues, I am sure they will not.

+1
-2
-1
CC '14 posted on

Sure, fine, but look: frats can't have their cake and eat it too. They can't one minutes say to the Brownstone Review Committee, "We are a part of the community at large," and then the next minute, when they fuck up, say, "This is our business, it's a private affair that isn't relevant to the community at large."

+1
+1
-1
CC '14 posted on

Sure, fine, but look: frats can't have their cake and eat it too. They can't one minutes say to the Brownstone Review Committee, "We are a part of the community at large," and then the next minute, when they fuck up, say, "This is our business, it's a private affair that isn't relevant to the community at large."

+1
+2
-1
yesthattrollagain posted on

This was not mishandled, as far as they are concerned. This has always reflected their intentions. See, Columbia administrators and leaders have criminal minds.

+1
-8
-1
Anonymous posted on

The hazing was organized by the field hockey team. The players were gagged by the administration. The kegs were a baseball celebration. Athletics and alcohol are Columbia's unanswerable questions. The NCAA looms large, as does a paradox of diversely separate housing. ZBT was yesterday's answer.

+1
+1
-1
wHAEOmxc posted on

buy xanax generic xanax pictures information - generic for xanax side effects

+1
0
-1
CbCwKS posted on

how much is yours worth? best dosage tramadol - tramadol 50mg vs 100mg

+1
0
-1
oHgyEmdr posted on

buy xanax online can buy xanax vietnam - ativan vs xanax side effects

+1
0
-1
eUCwrYkK posted on

tramadol no prescription buy tramadol online without rx - tramadol 50mg side effects dogs

+1
0
-1
uQflEanG posted on

tramadol online buy tramadol cod fedex - tramadol dosage mg/kg

+1
0
-1
MehIaxdM posted on

buy tramadol tramadol 50mg my dog - purchase cheap tramadol online

+1
0
-1
dHInL posted on

order xanax how long xanax drug screen - xanax bars yellow time release

+1
0
-1
sMMKu posted on

Look At This cheap xanax online no rx - xanax 2mg white

+1
0
-1
sHgTKHjHS posted on

how can i buy valium online 10 mg valium effects - how will 10mg valium affect me

+1
0
-1
enLuiyqpE posted on

valium online safe order valium online - valium tablet size

+1
0
-1
AibAJvkD posted on

buy roche 10mg valium dosage of valium for dogs - prospecto valium 0 5

+1
0
-1
UyfGjsDP posted on

buy valium online mastercard valium injection - buy valium online without rx

+1
0
-1
PBgCcDku posted on

buy valium belfast buy real valium online - sweet valium high charlotte sometimes

+1
0
-1
GosAGhYO posted on

buy valium valium dosage range - better high valium or xanax

+1
0
-1
OSTxoTGk posted on

generic adderall adderall 30 mg withdrawal - adderall and alcohol and prozac

+1
0
-1
SNiXz posted on

Read Full Article can tramadol withdrawal kill you - tramadol withdrawal canine

+1
0
-1
ayidoJ posted on

ambien online no prescription ambien withdrawal wiki - ambien drug test false positives

+1
0
-1
FwXqBX posted on

blog soma medication migraines - soma online ticketing

+1
0
-1
LTKiro posted on

image source is it legal to purchase ambien online - discount ambien online

+1
0
-1
InmPJ posted on

Continue ambien discount card - buy ambien pills online

+1
0
-1
PROzC posted on

Read Full Report ambien 20 mg side effects - ambien cr sales 2009

+1
0
-1
iXWEGU posted on

homepage ambience mall gurgaon food outlets - can ambien cr 12.5 be split

+1
0
-1