A&E

Competing visions in "Lost in Translation" and "Her"

"Lost in Translation" struck me as the right movie for this week because Oscar season is coming up and it presents a very dramatic juxtaposition with one of the Best Picture contenders.

You see, Sofia Coppola, the writer-director of "Lost in Translation," which won for Best Original Screenplay, and Spike Jonze, writer-director of "Her," which is expected to win Best Original Screenplay this year, used to be Hollywood’s big couple. While art should be taken for its own sake, it’s a lot more fun to view these movies as thinly veiled statements, and they give us a lot of good reasons to do so. The similarities between these two movies, although years apart, are compelling. Both use Scarlett Johansson as the love interest and take place in gleaming, impersonal Asian cities (Tokyo in "Translation" and Shanghai digitally imposed on LA in "Her"). Besides their eerily similar aesthetic, both protagonists deal with failing or failed relationships by finding totally different connections with new strangers.

Jonze’s Theodore Twombly is recovering from a failed relationship with an ex-wife who grew tired of him and left, and he was powerless to stop her. "Her" was made many years after "Lost in Translation," and Twombly is a man who is still scarred by a relationship that has been over for a while. The movie, partly because of the limitations of one character without a body, is just overflowing with pretty words and turns of phrase. Oftentimes it feels as if he can take liberty with his beautiful shots because they just feel like ornament to the true action going on, which is internal. They complement the scene, but never dictate it.

Coppola’s surrogate, not the main character Bill Murray but the protagonist played by ScarJo, is stuck alone in Japan with an absolute dweeb caricature of a photographer husband. He’s just too busy to really notice her and feels like he is trying to be too hip for his own skin. Coppola’s movie is built almost entirely on long silences to the point where it feels like it plays out in real time. It is the smallest physical movements, or oftentimes the silences, that provide the movie’s most powerful moments. While "Her" takes place over a longer period of time, and while it is easier to admire as an intellectual achievement, "Translation" proves elicit the more immersive, poignant experience for me.

"Her" begins with Theodore writing a love letter, but he is just putting his care into writing someone else’s story as part of his job. You can still see that it’s crafted with passion, but that this passion doesn’t transfer to his life outside. At the end of the movie, Theodore writes a letter to his ex-wife, acknowledging the mistakes he made with her and is ready to move on. It’s very hard not to put the two together. Just replace his card-writing with film-making and it’s almost complete. There’s a ton to read out of these two. What do you see? Make predictions or pick a side on this argument in the comments.

Comments

Plain text

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Carl posted on

Exactly what I thought when I saw "Her". Also another odd coincidence is that Sofia Coppola and Spike Jonze used to be married.

+1
-1
-1
Herve Leger Sale posted on

Shop herve leger sale at http://www.hervelegerpower.com . Shop the latest collection of herve leger cheap from the most popular stores - all in the cheapest place.
Herve Leger Sale http://www.hervelegerpower.com

+1
0
-1
ElbertGafe posted on

prix cialis
acquistare cialis
cialis generico
http://achetercialisgeneriqueenlignefrance.com/ cialis acheter
http://acquistarepillolecialisgenericoitalia.com/ cialis acquistare
http://comprarcialiscomprimidogenericoespana.com/ cialis

+1
0
-1
Herve Leger posted on

Find herve leger sale at http://www.hervelegerpower.com . Shop the latest collection of herve leger sale from the most popular stores - all in the cheapest place.
Herve Leger http://www.hervelegerpower.com

+1
0
-1
Herve Leger Sale posted on

Find herve leger sale at http://www.hervelegerpower.com . Shop the latest collection of herve leger sale from the most popular stores - all in the cheapest place.
Herve Leger Sale http://www.hervelegerpower.com

+1
0
-1
NFL jerseys posted on

Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasant opinion, paragraphis pleasant, thats why i have read it completely such as NFL jerseys wholesale.
NFL jerseys http://www.controlspecialists.co.uk/nfl/controlspecialists-nfl-wholesale.asp/

+1
0
-1
wholesale nfl jerseys posted on

There are many fantastic publishing ideas and links of interest for you in regard to the wholesale nfl jerseys For the Loved ones board, as well as board etiquette and terminology to create your knowledge right here a lot easier.
wholesale nfl jerseys http://www.controlspecialists.co.uk/nfl/controlspecialists-nfl-wholesale.asp/

+1
0
-1
2014新着 キラキラ リング posted on

water without a source, and a tree wiithout roots

2014新着 キラキラ リング http://shopping.geocities.jp/icloudjp/index.html

+1
0
-1
ElbertGafe posted on

cialis generique
acheter cialis
prezzo cialis
comprar cialis
http://achetercialisgeneriqueenlignefrance.com/ achat cialis
http://acquistarepillolecialisgenericoitalia.com/ cialis acquistare
http://comprarcialiscomprimidogenericoespana.com/ cialis

+1
0
-1
GeorgeFums posted on

achat viagra commander viagra sur internet
http://acheterviagrageneriquepascher.com/ vente viagra
precio viagra precio viagra 50 mg
http://precioviagragenericoespana.com/ viagra sin receta
acquisto viagra acquistare viagra
http://prezzoviagragenericosenzaricetta.com/ prezzo viagra
viagra bestellen kaufen viagra 25mg
http://viagrapreisegenerika.com/ viagra kaufen

+1
0
-1
Wholesale MLB Jerseys posted on

Your dynamic delivery kept me alert, and involved. It was a very rewarding experience for me. Thank you for sharing your time, your knowledge and your sense of humor. Janice M.
Wholesale MLB Jerseys http://www.fdlgroup.co.uk/images/mlbwholesale.asp

+1
0
-1
achat viagra posted on

achat viagra acheter viagra
http://acheterviagragneriquefrance50mg.com/ acheter viagra
viagra acquisto viagra prezzo
http://acquistareviagragenericosenzaricetta.com/ comprare viagra
comprar viagra viagra sin receta
http://comprarviagragenericobarato.com/ precio viagra
viagra deutschland viagra generika
http://viagragenerikakaufendeutschland.net/ viagra bestellen

+1
0
-1