News | Student Life

Iranian mission rescinds CIRCA invite

Members of Columbia's international relations group CIRCA will not be attending a dinner with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad on Wednesday after the invitation was rescinded by the Iranian mission to the UN.

The change of plans followed a week and a half of extensive media attention on the dinner plans, including an erroneous Fox News report that University President Lee Bollinger would be attending the dinner and other incorrect reports stating that the University was hosting the event. Students had also organized an on-campus protest for noon on Wednesday, called "Just Say No to Ahma(dinner)jad."

CIRCA members said that they were informed by the mission on Monday that its students were no longer invited to the dinner in the wake of the media firestorm.

But other students will still be attending the dinner, which will take place as scheduled on Wednesday. Ahmadinejad has previously held private dinners with students, diplomats, professors and others, and representatives from Yale and New York University have attended in the past. CIRCA members said that even though their invitation had been revoked, students from Columbia's School of International and Public Affairs would still be attending.

Over the summer, members of the group were told that they might be able to take 15 students to dinner with the head of state, whose views on Israel, human rights, and homosexuality have drawn sharp criticism. Ahmadinejad is in town to attend the annual United Nations General Assembly.

CIRCA member Rich Medina, CC '13, who had planned to attend the dinner, said that members were never going to the event because they supported Ahmadinejad's views, but rather as a chance to talk to a world leader. And despite the outcry, Medina said he would have liked "to engage on that level with someone who is such a hot topic in international affairs," adding that it would have been a rare opportunity for dialogue.

"This would have been an interesting academic experience," he said.

In the last two weeks, CIRCA members and the University were subjected to a barrage of criticism from conservative columnists and groups like the Zionist Organization of America. Club members said that they have received dozens of hostile emails, and at one point last week the club decided not to comment further in order to protect its members' personal safety.

Last week, the University issued a statement denying any involvement with the dinner. "At no time has there ever been any university event planned or considered involving the president of Iran, nor has there ever been any plan for a dinner involving the Iranian president and President Bollinger,” it read.

Medina added that when the club received news of the invitations, he didn't even expected the dinner to go through.

"I was very unsurprised when they cancelled, because we received a similar answer last year," Medina said. "Last year it was an invitation to have tea at his hotel," which he said was canceled a week later.

The Iranian mission to the United Nations would not comment, saying it had no knowledge of a dinner.

In 2007, Ahmadinejad made waves at Columbia for his speech as part of the World Leaders Forum, setting off a campus-wide debate over academic freedom and Iranian politics, as well as protests surrounding the event.

The student-planned protest against Ahmadinejad this time around will not be canceled, even though CIRCA members won't be attending the dinner, said organizer David Fine, CC '13.

Fine, who organized the protest along with Jacob Snider, CC '13, Eric Schapiro, CC '13, and Sam Schube, CC '12, said that "Just Say No to Ahma(dinner)jad" will be renamed "Just Say No to Ahmadinejad."

"The only thing that's changed is that we're not going to talk about the dinner," Fine said. "The key thing that made the dinner so salient was the serial abuses of human rights that are committed by Mahmoud Ahmadinejad every day against Iranian people."

Still, many students, including SIPA student Diana Ramos, said that opposing views shouldn't mean that students are condemned for speaking with Ahmadinejad, or that he shouldn't speak to American students.

"That's the whole point of international affairs," Ramos said.

Abby Abrams and Jackie Carrero contributed reporting.


Plain text

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Your username will not be displayed if checked
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Anonymous posted on

This is a totally drummed up controversy on all fronts. The entire event is a publicity stunt; if people from CIRCA want to go have dinner with a despot, then they're more than welcome need to make public announcements about how excited they are and to embroil the entire university in controversy. The erroneous outside reporting on all of this speaks for itself--it's clear that certain news outlets are lacking for things to write about.

Anonymous posted on

  Jewish Defense Organization
 JDO is angry that again under pig president bollinger this is happening.First Ahmaddiejad Hitler of Iran should not
have been invited to Columbia in the first place, jut so the college gets donations secretly from Iranian Governemtn.JDO is calliing on all Jewish alumni to cut off theri donations.Also march on Bollinger's home. Last how would black studnrts react if Bollinger dared to invite the grand racist lizard of Ku Klux Klan David Duke  to talk about lynching innocent blacks ?
 That would not even happen as Black styudents would stop that from happening.We Jews should be just as militant about stopping the Hitler of Iran Ahamadinejad 1

DansDaMan posted on

You wanna "talk to a world leader?" Haven't you heard Netanyahu's in town?

Anonymous posted on

Indeed if you want to talk to Hitler don't forget ByBee!!!

Anonymous posted on

And despite the outcry, Medina said he would have liked "to engage on that level with someone who is such a hot topic in international affairs," adding that it would have been a rare opportunity for dialogue.
Really?  You think you could "engage" with this psychopath?  That YOU could create a "dialogue"?  About what?  Nukes and long range missiles?  Execution of gays?  Holocaust denial?  Oppression of free speech, women, etc.?  YOU would just be fodder for photo ops, but I guess that's ok, since he's a "hot topic".  Pathetic.  And the fact that Yale and NYU students have done it is not excuse.